Category: 42 Word Retrospectives

Prelude to Foundation

Prelude to Foundation

by Isaac Asimov (Doubleday, 1988)

audiobook read by William Hope (HarperVoyager, 2023)

Book cover: “Prelude to Foundation” by Isaac Asimov (Doubleday, 1988); audiobook read by William Hope (HarperVoyager, 2023)

Self-indulgent. Asimov trades on his name more than his ideas, with middling prose and revelatory twists that survive only through clumsy concealment beneath a glut of character-voiced speculation as to how future society might function. Hope’s Seldon accent is a brave choice.

The Cornish Coast Murder

The Cornish Coast Murder

by John Bude (Skeffington & Son, 1935)

audiobook read by Ben Allen (Soundings, 2016)

Book cover: “The Cornish Coast Murder” by John Bude (Skeffington & Son, 1935); audiobook read by Ben Allen (Soundings, 2016)

A simply told, engaging mystery featuring an amateur detective (a vicar) and a police inspector working in loose collaboration. While Bude rather gropes towards an understanding of the genre, his protagonists do likewise with the crime. The audiobook reading is decidedly Cornish.

Doctor Who: Voyager

Doctor Who: Voyager

by Steve Parkhouse; ill. John Ridgway; colours Gina Hart (Marvel, 1985)

Graphic novel cover: “Doctor Who: Voyager” by Steve Parkhouse; ill. John Ridgway; colours Gina Hart (Marvel, 1985)

Frobisher is introduced, joining a more proactive, less bombastic Sixth Doctor in an adventure trippy enough to have rounded out The Trial of a Time Lord. A preponderance of dark hues serves to foreground the SF (and make Baker’s coat blend in!).

Stop Making Sense

Stop Making Sense

by Talking Heads; dir. Jonathan Demme (1984) [2023 re-release]

Film poster: “Stop Making Sense” by Talking Heads; dir. Jonathan Demme (1984) [2023 re-release]

A concert film showcasing Talking Heads at the height of their powers as an extended ensemble. Rhythm and energy abound. David Byrne is quirky, neurotic and perhaps a tad too experimental in bringing a visual component to the music. Some songs expurgated.

Inspiration

Inspiration

by Kristine Kathryn Rusch (Fantasy & Science Fiction, November 1990)

Magazine cover: Fantasy & Science Fiction, November 1990; review of “Inspiration” by Kristine Kathryn Rusch

A short Christmas ghost story about a romance novelist and her spirit lover, whom she cannot touch because she was born after he died. The tragic tones give way to ick with the arrival of a rapist/stalker. Somewhat muddled in the denouement.

The Roman Hat Mystery

The Roman Hat Mystery

by Ellery Queen (Frederick A. Stokes, 1929)

audiobook read by Robert Fass (Blackstone, 2013)

Book cover: “The Roman Hat Mystery” by Ellery Queen (Frederick A. Stokes, 1929); audiobook read by Robert Fass (Blackstone, 2013)

An undemanding read in that the prose is straightforward and brooks no abridgement in relating every last action and brainstormed exchange of the investigation. The Queens are well drawn but the mystery conjures indifference, its solution buried beneath piles of mundane detail.

The Decagon House Murders

The Decagon House Murders

by Yukito Ayatsuji (1987); trans. Ho-Ling Wong (Locked Room, 2015)

audiobook read by P J Ochlan (Tantor, 2022)

Book cover: “The Decagon House Murders” by Yukito Ayatsuji (1987); trans. Ho-Ling Wong (Locked Room, 2015); audiobook read by P J Ochlan (Tantor, 2022)

Perhaps this novel suffers in translation. The English version features an ingenuous prose style full of grade-school descriptors and third-person narrative action shoehorned quite blithely into dialogue. The mystery, laboriously solved in recap, works far better conceptually than as a dramatic work.

Nurse Matilda

Nurse Matilda

by Christianna Brand (E.P. Dutton, 1964)

audiobook read by Phyllida Law (BBC Audio, 2009)

Book cover: “Nurse Matilda” by Christianna Brand (E.P. Dutton, 1964); audiobook read by Phyllida Law (BBC Audio, 2009)

Something of a one-note story. Nurse Matilda teaches an unruly horde of children to behave… by magicking them into gross over-indulgences of their original, naughty conduct. The book ends in a wearisome fever-dream recap of preceding events. The children are reformed. Bing.

Something Fresh

Something Fresh

by P G Wodehouse (Methuen, 1915)

audiobook read by Frederick Davidson (Blackstone, 1995)

Book cover: “Something Fresh” by P G Wodehouse (Methuen, 1915); audiobook read by Frederick Davidson (Blackstone, 1995)

The first Blandings Castle novel evinces much of Wodehouse’s penchant for twisty intertwinings of plot, and even more of his fondness (particularly in the early days) for facetious observation and scathing characterisation. Compared to later works, however, it’s all a bit artificial.