Category: 42 Word Retrospectives

The Confessions of Arsène Lupin

The Confessions of Arsène Lupin

by Maurice Leblanc (Éditions Pierre Lafitte, 1913)

audiobook read by Maxwell Caulfield, Juliet Mills & Stefan Rudnicki (Blackstone, 2020)

Book cover: “The Confessions of Arsène Lupin” by Maurice Leblanc (Éditions Pierre Lafitte, 1913); audiobook read by Maxwell Caulfield, Juliet Mills & Stefan Rudnicki (Blackstone, 2020)

Ten more stories in which self-styled gentleman thief Arsène Lupin outwits the French police (and everyone else), albeit he does survive a few close calls this volume. Leblanc crafts ingenious scenarios, lighter in narrative voice but no less memorable than Conan Doyle.

The Last Boy Scout (1991)

The Last Boy Scout

dir. Tony Scott (1991)

Film poster: “The Last Boy Scout” dir. Tony Scott (1991)

Heavy-handed buddy action film, very male at every level of production, with a candidate for worst-ever-acted villain (Taylor Negron as Milo), yet also laugh-out-loud funny and boasting oddly exquisite, throwaway snatches of dialogue. The Last Boy Scout soars higher with every rewatch.

Doctor Who: Slipback (1985)

Doctor Who: Slipback

by Eric Saward (BBC Radio 4, 1985)

Audio drama cover: “Doctor Who: Slipback” by Eric Saward (BBC Radio 4, 1985)

Slipback captures much of the Sixth Doctor zeitgeist but also attempts a Hitchhiker’s-style humour, which entirely fails to land. Valentine Dyall is given no interaction. The plot strands are barely developed (yet shamelessly rehashed). Hardly an advertisement for a programme on hiatus.

Death on the Cherwell

Death on the Cherwell

by Mavis Doriel Hay (Skeffington & Son, 1935)

audiobook read by Patience Tomlinson (Soundings, 2015)

Book cover: “Death on the Cherwell” by Mavis Doriel Hay (Skeffington & Son, 1935); audiobook read by Patience Tomlinson (Soundings, 2015)

Hay starts off with amateur detectives (students from the Oxford women’s college whose setting elevates the novel) then discards them—along with the obvious suspects—in favour of an avuncular Scotland Yard man whose deductive skills at no point outstrip the reader’s.

Yes Minister, Series 1

Yes Minister, Series 1

by Antony Jay & Jonathan Lynn (BBC 2, 1980)

TV poster: “Yes Minister, Series 1” by Antony Jay & Jonathan Lynn (BBC 2, 1980)

A slightly patchy satire, which in later series would become truly sublime in deriding British government and the Civil Service—both gleefully caricatured yet tellingly believable! The well-meaning but ductile Jim Hacker struggles to make headway against silver-tongued bureaucrat Sir Humphrey Appleby.

Third Year at Malory Towers

Third Year at Malory Towers

by Enid Blyton (Methuen, 1948)

audiobook read by Beth Eyre (Bolinda, 2021)

Book cover: “Third Year at Malory Towers” by Enid Blyton (Methuen, 1948); audiobook read by Beth Eyre (Bolinda, 2021)

Once again, Darrell is largely sidelined, Blyton leaning a little too heavily into everyday depictions… while reserving all the drama for three new characters! Still, the term breezes by and offers some tear-jerking highs amidst all the idyll of Malory Towers life.

Benny Hill’s Greatest Hits

Benny Hill’s Greatest Hits

(Thames Video, 1990)

VHS cover: “Benny Hill’s Greatest Hits” (Thames Video, 1990)

Hill’s humour was largely one-dimensional, his urgently titillated, naughty schoolboy expressions suggesting an immaturity that persisted through overweight middle-age and somehow found resonance across two decades of British viewership, tainting even the occasional clever (‘Weather Pair’) or madcap surreal (‘Wicked Warden’) piece.

Murder After Christmas

Murder After Christmas

by Rupert Latimer (Macdonald & Co., 1944)

audiobook read by Kris Dyer (Soundings, 2021)

Book cover: “Murder After Christmas” by Rupert Latimer (Macdonald & Co., 1944); audiobook read by Kris Dyer (Soundings, 2021)

A murder mystery most notable for obfuscating events behind a blanket barrage of affability. All the suspects have blithely joked about doing in Uncle Willie. Latimer plays endlessly with motive and opportunity, meandering up false trails until it all becomes quite tedious.

A Canticle for Leibowitz

A Canticle for Leibowitz

by Walter M. Miller Jr. (J. B. Lippincott & Co., 1959)

audiobook read by Tom Weiner (Blackstone, 2011)

Book cover: “A Canticle for Leibowitz” by Walter M. Miller Jr. (J. B. Lippincott & Co., 1959); audiobook read by Tom Weiner (Blackstone, 2011)

Award-winning but over-hyped. A drawn-out, wasteland-without-hope, of-its-time fix-up novel exploring notions of—and interactions between—religious belief, cyclical history, information systems and nuclear apocalypse. Miller builds detailed (if bleak and self-indulgent) scenarios. All three sections come to weigh portentously upon the reader.

Guess Who?

Guess Who?

by Philip E. High

New Worlds Science Fiction, Vol. 19, No. 56 (February 1957), 88-99.

Magazine cover: New Worlds Science Fiction, Vol. 19, No. 56 (February 1957); review of “Guess Who?” by Philip E. High, pp. 88-99.

SF short story in which High attempts to show up the military’s hard-ball pre-emptive aggression while also postulating how to deal with a ruthless species of telepathic shape-changers—an odd juxtaposition, as the latter come across as no better than the former.

Derelict Space Sheep