Category: 42 Word Retrospectives

The Second Form at Malory Towers

The Second Form at Malory Towers

by Enid Blyton (Methuen, 1947)

audiobook read by Beth Eyre (Bolinda, 2021)

Book cover: “The Second Form at Malory Towers” by Enid Blyton (Methuen, 1947); audiobook read by Beth Eyre (Bolinda, 2021)

Second Form introduces new characters and shifts the viewpoint away from Darrell (embracing an omniscient narrative). While the plot mirrors that of First Term, the girls have turned thirteen and the shading is less innocent. Thus the series grows alongside its readers.

A Murder is Announced

A Murder is Announced

by Agatha Christie (Collins Crime Club, 1950)

audiobook read by Joan Hickson (Lamplight, 2015)

Book cover: “A Murder is Announced” by Agatha Christie (Collins Crime Club, 1950); audiobook read by Joan Hickson (Lamplight, 2015)

Christie dollops out distinct, often irreverent personalities, and fashions an engaging murder mystery, albeit the scenario hangs on an unnaturally compressed timeline (to which the reader is only belatedly made privy). The omniscient narrative allows for different angles of sleuthing and deception.

The Golden Slipper, and Other Problems for Violet Strange

The Golden Slipper, and Other Problems for Violet Strange

by Anna Katharine Green (1915)

audiobook read by Shelly Frasier (Tantor, 2009) [as “Mystery Stories of Violet Strange”]

Book cover: “The Golden Slipper, and Other Problems for Violet Strange” by Anna Katharine Green (1915); audiobook read by Shelly Frasier (Tantor, 2009) [as “Mystery Stories of Violet Strange”]

This collection of detective novelettes holds up quite well, though their virtue lies more in the refined telling than in the mystery element (which often relies on highly improbable concatenations) or denouements (which generally lack catharsis). Violet herself makes a memorable impression.

Parting Breath

Parting Breath

by Catherine Aird (Collins, 1977)

audiobook read by Robin Bailey (Audible, 2014)

Book cover: “Parting Breath” by Catherine Aird (Collins, 1977); audiobook read by Robin Bailey (Audible, 2014)

The mystery is mostly a snooze-fest, unearthing itself to no great interest or enlightenment amidst the tangle of university life (laboriously depicted). The chief—indeed, only real—appeal lies in Sloan’s self-aware musings and stoically borne verbal exchanges with Crosby and Leeyes.

Moving Pictures

Moving Pictures

by Terry Pratchett (Victor Gollancz, 1990)

audiobook read by Jason Isaacs (Penguin, 2023)

Book cover: “Moving Pictures” by Terry Pratchett (Victor Gollancz, 1990); audiobook read by Jason Isaacs (Penguin, 2023)

The Discworld’s manifestation of Hollywood is funny moment-by-moment but something of a one-note spoof, offering little substance behind the humorous allusions and in-jokes (though maybe this is apt). As if to paper over the cracks, Pratchett throws in some utterly superfluous wizarding.

Mr. Jelly’s Business

Mr. Jelly’s Business

by Arthur W. Upfield (Angus & Robertson, 1937)

audiobook read by Peter Hosking (Bolinda, 2012)

Book cover: “Mr. Jelly’s Business” by Arthur W. Upfield (Angus & Robertson, 1937); audiobook read by Peter Hosking (Bolinda, 2012)

Bony seems more vigorous in his investigations here than elsewhere, and is portrayed with flaws and failings to counterbalance his abilities (and most of all, pride). Though the dialogue tends toward the stilted side of formal, the characters nevertheless prove distinctly Australian.

Derelict Space Sheep