Category: 42 Word Reviews

Sherlock: The Reichenbach Fall

Sherlock: The Reichenbach Fall

by Stephen Thompson; dir. Toby Haynes (BBC, 2012)

Postage stamp: “Sherlock: The Reichenbach Fall” by Stephen Thompson; dir. Toby Haynes (BBC, 2012)

Another clever (if frenetic) script, reworking Conan Doyle’s ‘The Final Problem’ and cramming a whole series of character arcs into one episode. While Andrew Scott (Moriarty) positively steals the show, Rupert Graves (Lestrade) proves subtly effective, grounding the mad turn of events.

Hawkeye: Private Eye

Hawkeye: Private Eye

by Kelly Thompson; ill. Leonardo Romero & Michael Walsh (Marvel, 2019)

Book cover: “Hawkeye: Private Eye” by Kelly Thompson; ill. Leonardo Romero & Michael Walsh (Marvel, 2019)

A thick, glossy, vibrant collection. Kate Bishop’s Hawkeye is sassy, fantastic, and self-aware enough to spoof the genre while playing to its strengths and traditions. The storytelling (dialogue, art and layout) is full of personality. A dark yet colourful, action-packed, fun-loving romp.

The Address Book

The Address Book: What Street Addresses Reveal about Identity, Race, Wealth and Power

by Deirdre Mask (Profile, 2020)

Book cover: “The Address Book: What Street Addresses Reveal about Identity, Race, Wealth and Power” by Deirdre Mask (Profile, 2020)

Fascinating, yet oddly unfocussed and unsystematic—like many of the address systems detailed within. Mask drifts around the world, being interested in things and darting from idea to offshoot but never quite elevating her subject matter to something more than historical trivia.

Doctor Who: Conflict Theory

Doctor Who: Conflict Theory

by Nev Fountain; dir. Scott Handcock (BBC, 2020)

Box set cover: "The Sixth Doctor and Peri, Volume One"; review of "“Doctor Who: Conflict Theory” by Nev Fountain; dir. Scott Handcock (BBC, 2020)

A fun, frivolous story that, beneath clever execution, explores the more serious question of the Doctor’s culpability in exposing his companions to danger. Fountain’s script is spot-on. Colin Baker and Nicola Bryant revel in a character dynamic rarely done justice on television.

Beyond the Wand

Beyond the Wand: The Magic and Mayhem of Growing up a Wizard

by Tom Felton (Grand Central Publishing, 2022)

audiobook read by Tom Felton (Hachette Audio, 2022)

Book cover: “Beyond the Wand: The Magic and Mayhem of Growing up a Wizard” by Tom Felton (Grand Central Publishing, 2022); audiobook read by Tom Felton (Hachette Audio, 2022)

Felton seems an affable type, especially reading his own memoir. He is serious where the subject matter demands it but mostly keeps things light, offering behind-the-scenes insights into a child actor’s life generally and the Harry Potter films and cast in particular.

Harrow the Ninth

Harrow the Ninth

by Tamsyn Muir (Tor, 2020)

audiobook read by Moira Quirk (Recorded Books, 2020)

Book cover: “Harrow the Ninth” by Tamsyn Muir (Tor, 2020); audiobook read by Moira Quirk (Recorded Books, 2020)

Muir contrives to make this sequel as disorientating for fans of the first book as it would be for new readers. The story retains its compelling allure (credit again to Moira Quirk’s reading) but the immersive mystery-solving devolves into exposition and setup.

Valerian

Valerian and the City of a Thousand Planets

dir. Luc Besson (2017)

Film poster: “Valerian and the City of a Thousand Planets” dir. Luc Besson (2017)

Visually arresting. Besson invests in the SF setting from grand scheme to background detail, creating a plush stage for the space opera. Unfortunately, the storyline shows its comic-book origins. The action scenes are mostly pointless and the big emotional moments fall flat.

A Forgery of Roses

A Forgery of Roses

by Jessica S. Olson (Inkyard Press, 2022)

audiobook read by Billie Fulford-Brown (Harlequin, 2022)

Book cover: “A Forgery of Roses” by Jessica S. Olson (Inkyard Press, 2022); audiobook read by Billie Fulford-Brown (Harlequin, 2022)

Myra is a frustrating protagonist, slow on the uptake and blown without thought or hesitation by conflicting winds of speculative mystery and YA romance. While the storytelling is competent, the characterisation is heavy-handed. The juxtaposition of tropes induces a persistent, jarring wince.

Dylan Moran: Monster

Dylan Moran: Monster

(Live in Dublin, April 2004)

DVD cover: “Dylan Moran: Monster” (Live in Dublin, April 2004)

Moran is an unprepossessing, boyishly unkempt presence on stage, at once sardonically amused at life and yet vaguely irritated by it, flailing after observational threads and, when sufficiently piqued, latching on to sublimely absurd stream-of-consciousness exemplars, caught and released with rapid-fire insouciance.

Froi of the Exiles

Froi of the Exiles

by Melina Marchetta (Viking, 2011)

audiobook read by Grant Cartwright (ABC Audio, 2012)

Book cover: “Froi of the Exiles” by Melina Marchetta (Viking, 2011); audiobook read by Grant Cartwright (ABC Audio, 2012)

Marchetta’s trilogy goes from strength to strength. The shift of protagonists allows for reinvention within the fantasy framework, but the biggest contribution to genre remains the subversive female perspective stitched between threads. A long novel but one that demands to be read.